What’s better than cake and ice cream? A cake MADE from ice cream! Our ice cream cakes begin with a bottom layer of chocolate cookie crumbs, a layer of chocolate custard, another layer of chocolate cookie crumbs (because let’s face it, everyone loves the chocolate cookie crumbs!), a layer of yummy hot fudge, and finally, a layer of vanilla custard. We then top each cake with a delicious whipped frosting that is – in our opinion – out of this world! We will also customize your ice cream cake to order*. You can choose from delicious additions including peanut butter sauce, strawberries, and more!

Stop in today and pick up one of our delicious ice cream cakes for your next party or work function!

*For custom cakes, we require orders be placed at least 48 hours in advance. Contact us today! 


  • Round Cake – $26.99
    • Serves approximately 6-10 people
    • Add peanut butter, or strawberries for just $2.50.
  • Rectangular Cake – $36.99
    • Serves approximately 15-25 people
    • Add peanut butter, or strawberries for just $5.00.
  • Half Sheet – $73.98
    • Pre-order only 
    • Serves approximately 40-50 people
    • Add peanut butter, or strawberries for just $10.00.


First ice cream, then ice cream cakes, and now, the perfect little treat – an ice cream cupcake! Perfect for birthday parties, bridal and baby showers, and more! Our cupcakes are made with a layer of everyone’s favorite chocolate cookie crumbs, your choice of hard ice cream or our creamy custard, they are then dipped in chocolate and are topped off with our delicious whipped frosting, rainbow sprinkles and a cherry on top. They are available in quantities of 6 only. Contact us today!


  • ½ Dozen – $15.00
  • 1 Dozen – $28.99
  • 2 Dozen – $57.98
  • 3 Dozen – $86.97
  • 4 Dozen – $115.96
  • 5 Dozen – $144.95

We require custom ice cream cupcake orders to be placed at least 48 hours in advance. For larger orders we may require more time. We can make as many ice cream cupcakes as you need, just call us for pricing. Order yours today! (585)352-6795


What’s a sandwich without ice cream?! Not sure what to make for dessert? Pick up a pack of LuGia’s ice cream sandwiches – the perfect snack or ending to any meal. LuGia’s ice cream sandwiches come filled with your choice of our delicious custard: vanilla, chocolate, vanilla/chocolate twist, black raspberry, black raspberry/vanilla twist sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. They are available for individual purchase or in packs of six.

  • Single Sandwiches – $1.99
  • 6 Packs – $10.00

Ice Cream Cannolis

Crispy cannoli shells, baked with a hint of cinnamon and filled with our famous custard, finished with a drizzle of chocolate and a dusting of rainbow sprinkles.

  • 2 for $5.97


Our customers are an extension of our family, and what better way to show your love for LuGia’s than to sport one of our t-shirts or hats? Choose your favorite flavor (okay, color) and size, but don’t worry, unlike our ice cream, our apparel comes in more sizes than BIG. Stop in and pick up your LuGia’s t-shirt and hat today! They’re perfect for the whole family.

  • T-Shirts – $11.99
  • Hats – $15.00
  • Hoodies – $27.96